Maintaining Physical Activity in Older Adult MCO Members

Principal Investigator: Brian C. Martinson, Ph.D. Health Partners Research Foundation

Abstract:

The benefits of physical activity for adults are well established, but less than one-third of older adults in the U.S. have achieved recommended levels of physical activity despite widespread clinical recommendations to increase physical activity in recent years. Clinic-based approaches to increasing physical activity are expensive, difficult to implement in busy practice settings, and have limited reach. Moreover, evidence of the efficacy of such approaches is equivocal. A population based approach may be a more effective and less costly strategy to increase levels of physical activity in older adults. Population studies of physical activity have demonstrated that each year, many sedentary older adults initiate physical activity, but a nearly equal number of those who were active become sedentary. Among older adults initiating physical activity, only half continue to be active 3 months later.

We hypothesize that a population based approach that emphasizes physical activity maintenance can substantially increase physical activity levels in a defined populations of older adults. This hypothesis is tested in a 24-month randomized trial evaluating an innovative, theory-based behavioral intervention to maintain physical activity in a random sample of 50-70 year old adults who have recently become at least moderately active. One thousand (1000) subjects will be randomized to one of two experimental groups: 1) a “usual care” control group, and 2) an interactive phone- and mail-based intervention program tailored to maintaining physical activity in older adults. The primary outcome measures are: 1) physical activity, assessed as kcals/wk expenditure; and 2) physical activity maintenance, assessed as follow-up kcals/wk expenditure relative to baseline. Careful measurement of the penetration of the intervention into a well characterized older adult population, and the costs of the intervention, will be assessed. Psychosocial and behavioral mediators of physical activity maintenance will also be examined.

Study results will be relevant to policy makers, health promotion practitioners and health plans, and will provide practical information on the effectiveness, population penetration, and costs of an intervention designed to maximize population levels of physical activity among older adults.

Specific Aims:

This research will address these issues by evaluating the efficacy of a population-based approach to promoting PA maintenance among currently active older adults in a managed care setting. The primary goal is to evaluate the efficacy of an innovative intervention to maintain PA levels among older adults. The research will assess the degree to which the intervention can penetrate the target population, and will provide data on the costs of the intervention, as well as its benefits. The specific aims of the proposed study are as follows.

  1. To identify and recruit newly active older male and female members (age 50-70 years old) of a large managed care organization and follow them over a 24-month period. Recruitment will be performed through phone and mail-based screening of a random subset of members.

    1. To conduct a randomized trial comparing: Usual care (control): These members will be followed for 24 months, but will not receive any physical activity intervention or advice beyond what is typically provided to health plan members.

    2. Telephone- and mail-based intervention: This group will be offered an interactive support program, provided through telephone-based cognitive-behavioral counseling, with additional mail-based support.
  2. To evaluate the primary program outcomes, which are:

Absolute level of physical activity: Assessed at baseline, 3, 6, 12 and 24-month follow-up as kcals/wk expenditure based on survey self-report.

Maintenance of physical activity: Physical activity level relative to baseline assessed at all follow-ups.

4. Secondary outcomes include:

Population penetration: Proportion of those eligible who agree to join the study, and proportion of those randomized to the intervention condition who complete the intervention protocol.

Mediating Factors: Level of physical activity self-efficacy, social support for physical activity, and perceived benefits and barriers to activity will also be assessed at baseline and the 3, 6, 12, and 24-month follow-ups. It is hypothesized that participants in the intervention condition will report higher levels of self-efficacy, social support, and perceived benefits of physical activity and lower levels of sedentary behavior and perceived barriers to physical activity at follow-up; these variables should mediate the efficacy of the intervention.