BHRC Project Driving and Substance Abuse

Principal Investigator: Sandra C. Lapham, M.D., MPH Behavioral Health Research Center of the Southwest

Abstract:

This R01 grant application requests 5 years of funding to extend the observation period of a cohort of first-time driving while impaired (DWI) offenders to 15 years. Subjects were first observed at the time of court-mandated referral for substance abuse evaluation to a screening program in Albuquerque, NM for a first DWI offense (1989-1992). A subset of 1,396 offenders was interviewed 5 years later where current and 12-month diagnoses of substance use and other psychiatric disorders were ascertained. A current secondary analysis grant examines the longitudinal database developed for the 5-year follow-up study. For the proposed study we will locate, and conduct structured, in-person interviews with the entire cohort of participants in the 5-year follow-up study. An estimated 71% of subjects can be located, with 5% deceased. A pilot study revealed a high (92%) willingness to participate, yielding an estimated total of 750 subjects (35% non-Hispanic White; 47% Hispanic; 15% American Indian; 3% other races; 56% of subjects are females). Interviews and questionnaires will measure the 15-year progression of alcohol use and other psychiatric disorders; examine attributes of subjects who achieved sobriety with and without the aid of formal and informal treatment; determine long-term rates of driving outcomes, including violations, crashes, and DWI arrests; and evaluate two alternative theoretical models (i.e., the Social-Control, and the Cognitive-Behavioral models) in predicting long-term, drinking/driving and traffic outcomes. Finally, through conduct of a qualitative study with a subset of offenders, we will assess subjects’ self-report information and variability in long-term maintenance of sobriety and relapse. Prevalence of alcohol and drug abuse/dependence, and mental health diagnoses will be ascertained through well-specified diagnostic criteria. Rates will be compared between genders and between Hispanic and non-Hispanic White subjects. Driving outcomes will be ascertained by self-report and using computer-based archival record data for those who still reside in New Mexico (estimated to be about 88% of subjects). Driving after drinking is the largest single cause of alcohol-related deaths in the U.S., and over one third of drivers in alcohol-related crashes have previous drunk-driving arrests. Yet few studies have examined long-term outcomes of convicted drunk drivers. Longer-term follow-up in this DWI sample, already described in rich detail, could add much to the body of knowledge regarding drunk drivers. The ability to collect long-term follow-up data coupled with theory development and an integrated empirical focus will provide a unique contribution to the development of prevention and treatment programs for both female and male offenders.

Specific Aims

This R01 grant application requests 5 years of funding to extend the observation period of a cohort of first-time driving while impaired (DWI) offenders to 15 years. Subjects are non-Hispanic white, Hispanic, and American Indian offenders of both genders, who were first observed at the time of court-mandated referral for substance abuse evaluation to the Lovelace Comprehensive Screening Program (LCSP; 1989-1991). A subset of 1,396 offenders was interviewed 5 years after screening, where current and 12-month diagnoses of substance use and other psychiatric disorders were ascertained. A recently funded secondary analysis grant titled “Testing explicit theoretical models of drinking/driving" (current study) will provide in-depth empirical analyses of the longitudinal database developed during the 5-year follow-up. This current study will establish typologies based on the constellation of psychological attributes, cognitive behavioral profiles, and drinking styles; and clarify the contribution of cognitive processes and psychiatric symptoms to alcohol dependence vulnerability.

The proposed study advances earlier work by expanding the follow-up period to 15 years and by integrating the findings from the current study into a broader explanatory framework that accounts for drunk-driving behavior. Subjects will be located and re-interviewed to determine long-term outcomes of substance abuse/dependence and drinking/driving. We will determine what aspects of recovery can be attributed to natural processes or treatment, and determine the applied utility of a social-control model in elucidating the role of risk and protective factors for drinking/driving. The project profits from our unusually expansive and rich data regarding drinking and driving behaviors in a community sample of convicted offenders. The ability to collect long-term follow-up data coupled with theory development and an integrated empirical focus will provide a unique contribution to the development of prevention and treatment programs for drunk drivers.

This study aims to:

(1)
Measure the long-term progression of alcohol use and other psychiatric disorders among convicted drunk-driving offenders, and the main effects of gender and ethnicity on these conditions;

(2)
Establish the extent to which natural recovery (no treatment), formal, and informal treatment are significantly associated with remission from alcohol and drug use disorders;

(3)
Determine long-term rates of driving outcomes, including violations, crashes, and DWI arrests, through self-reports; and the rates of traffic outcomes validated with archival traffic records for those subjects residing in-state during the follow-up period;

(4)
Corroborate the Cognitive-Behavioral theoretical model obtained from the current study R03 secondary analyses with longitudinal data from the 15-year follow-up study;

(5)
Contrast the performance of an alternative theoretical model (i.e., the Social-Control model) with those of the Cognitive-Behavioral model in predicting long-term, self-reported drinking/driving and traffic outcomes of previously convicted offenders;

(6)
Assess the extent to which the subjects’ self-report information explains variability in long-term maintenance of sobriety, non-problematic drinking, or continued problematic drinking, and drinking/driving, using qualitative interview techniques in a smaller random sample of subjects.